If you’re planning a new roof, one of the first things to decide is which material to use. Metal and asphalt shingles are two of the most popular options. They both offer benefits, but each one has trade-offs too. In this guide, we’ll compare them clearly to help you choose what fits your home and budget.
Cost Differences Between Metal and Asphalt Shingles
To begin, let’s look at how these two roofing materials compare in terms of cost, both now and later.
Initial Roof Costs
Asphalt shingles usually cost less up front. You can expect to pay around USD$1 to USD$5 per square foot. Metal roofing, on the other hand, runs from USD$5 to USD$12 per square foot.
Labor costs also matter. Asphalt shingles are easier and faster to install. That means lower labor charges. Metal takes more time and skill, which makes the labor more expensive.
For homeowners trying to compare real project costs or unsure which option fits their situation, it’s often helpful to speak directly with roof replacement contractors who can provide detailed quotes and explain what to expect based on your roof type and location.
Long-Term Costs and Value
Over time, metal roofing may save you more money. Why? It lasts much longer. A metal roof can last 40 to 70 years. Asphalt shingles typically last 15 to 30 years.
Metal roofs also require less maintenance. They don’t crack, shrink, or wear out as easily. So, you’ll likely spend less on repairs over the years. Much like running a lawn care business, choosing metal roofing is a smart move for those thinking long-term, prioritizing durability and minimizing ongoing upkeep costs.
Performance and Durability
Next, let’s talk about how well each roof type holds up over time and in tough weather conditions.
Weather Resistance and Lifespan
Metal roofs are very strong. They stand up well to high winds, hail, and snow. They also handle heat and sun without warping. Asphalt shingles have gotten better, but they still may wear down faster in harsh weather.
If you’re not sure which material suits your local climate best, a climate-based roof selection guide can help you compare roofing options based on weather conditions and home style.
Risk of Water Damage and Leaks
Both options can keep your home dry when installed correctly. However, metal tends to resist leaks better. Rainwater runs off easily, which helps reduce water damage over time.
Still, the quality of your roof deck and covering matters. A good roofing professional will make sure the entire system is sealed and secure.
Appearance and Curb Appeal
Now let’s look at how each option affects your home’s look and style.
Style Options
Asphalt shingles come in many colors and styles. Some even look like wood, tile, or slate. This makes them easy to match with most homes.
Metal roofs have more design choices than they used to. You can find them in many colors, textures, and patterns. Some styles even look like traditional shingles or clay tiles.
Curb Appeal and Resale Value
A new roof boosts curb appeal and is always a big-impact home renovation project no matter which type you choose. Metal roofing often looks more modern or upscale, which can be attractive to buyers. Asphalt gives a more classic look that fits well in many neighborhoods.
In both cases, a well-installed roof adds value and makes your home more inviting from the outside.
Installation and Building Requirements
Let’s move on to the installation process and local rules you may need to follow.
Roof Installation Process
Installing asphalt shingles usually takes a few days. It’s quick and doesn’t require special equipment. Metal takes more time. It also needs more skill and tools. That’s why it’s important to hire a roofing contractor with experience in metal installation.
In some cases, metal can go over your current shingles. This can cut down on labor costs.
Building Codes and Local Rules
Your town or city may have rules about what roofing materials are allowed. For example, some areas require fire-resistant materials. Others may limit certain roof types in places with strong winds or heavy snow.
A roofing professional can check the building codes for you and make sure your roof meets all the local standards.
Environmental Impact and Energy Efficiency
If you’re thinking about energy savings or greener living, your roof choice can help.
Energy Savings
Metal roofing reflects sunlight. As a result, you may spend less on air conditioning.
Asphalt shingles tend to absorb more heat. Some types are made to reflect sunlight, but they’re still not as efficient as metal.
Recyclability and Sustainability
Metal roofs are often made from recycled materials. They can be fully recycled when it’s time to replace them. Asphalt shingles are harder to recycle and often end up in landfills.
So, if eco-friendliness is part of your plan, metal may be the better choice.
When to Choose One Over the Other
Still unsure which roof is best? Let’s look at which situations fit each type better.
Best Fit for Your Situation
Choose asphalt shingles if:
- You’re working with a tight budget
- You plan to move in the next 10 to 15 years
- Most homes in your area have shingle roofs
Choose metal roofing if:
- You want your roof to last 40 years or more
- You live where storms, snow, or strong winds are common
- Energy efficiency or sustainability is important to you
Some people also look into tile or slate roofs, which offer other styles. However, these are more expensive and may need extra roof support. For most homeowners, the choice comes down to metal versus asphalt.
Think about how long you’ll stay in your home, the local weather, and what look you prefer.
Conclusion
A new roof is a major investment. Both metal and asphalt shingles offer solid benefits. Metal costs more up front but lasts longer and saves energy. Asphalt shingles are cheaper and easier to install, and they still look great.
Before you decide, schedule a roof inspection. Talk to a trusted roofing contractor. They’ll help you understand your roof deck, check for water damage, and guide you through local building codes. That way, you’ll choose the best roofing system for your home and future plans.
