5 Local Roofing Companies in Huntington, NY Specializing in Residential Roof Replacement

Ankuu MishraWritten By Ankuu Mishra
Jim RamseyReviewed ByJim Ramsey
Updated on Nov 19, 2026

Replacing a roof is one of the highest costs a Long Island homeowner may face. Choosing the right contractor is just as important as picking good materials. The roofing companies in Huntington, NY, listed here were chosen based on their work experience, service areas, industry certifications, and customer reviews.

Why Huntington homeowners need a contractor they can trust

Suffolk County puts roofs through serious punishment. Nor’easters, hard summer heat, and salt air rolling off the Sound chew through shingles and showcase failing flashings far faster than anything an inland roof typically sees. A replacement done poorly isn’t just a cosmetic failure; it opens the door to water infiltration that silently compounds into structural damage over months.

Huntington homeowners also face a contractor market that’s anything but direct. Storm season floods the part of the area with out-of-region companies dangling quick bids, and lot of them don’t carry Long Island licensing or stick with them to answer for problems that surface later. The gap between a 10-year roof and a 30-year roof usually goes back to who installed it; materials alone don’t account for the difference.

1. Smart Choice Contracting

Founded in 1999, Smart Choice Contracting is a Huntington-based residential roofing company with more than 26 years in the local market. Owner Mike Falco himself performs every estimate- no sales reps, no commissioned crews doing upsells.

What they do: Roof replacement, roof repair, roof inspections, asphalt shingle installation, vinyl siding, and gutter guard installation across all of Nassau and Suffolk County. They run 24/7 emergency services for storm damage and continuous leaks.

Where they stand out: Smart Choice Contracting holds Owens Corning Platinum Preferred status, one of only nine such contractors on Long Island. That certification gives you 50-year full labor and product warranties, significantly longer than what most area roofers can give. Every job uses hot-dip galvanized nails, which outlast standard fasteners by almost 15 years. The company has completed 2,000-plus roof installations and carries a 5.0 rating across 96 customer reviews. Flexible financing choices through Service Finance include 0% interest for five years; cash customers get a 15% discount, and active military, veterans, and first responders qualify for special pricing. Estimates cost nothing and come with detailed line-item breakdowns, no hidden fees.

2. Valorli

Valorli (operating as Valor Roofing) is a Long Island roofing company with 30-plus years of experience serving both Nassau and Suffolk Counties; it also includes Huntington and more than 40 surrounding communities starting from Valley Stream till Hampton Bays.

What they do: Residential and commercial roof replacement, roof repair, and leak diagnosis. The company takes care of insurance claims guidance as part of its client services, which is a practical advantage for homeowners dealing with storm-damage situations.

Where they stand out: Valorli offers a 30-year guarantee on all work and aims to complete most roof replacements within a single day. Owner Tommy’s personal involvement is mentioned repeatedly in customer reviews, alongside detailed cleanup procedures and on-time performance. Free, no-obligation inspections are available with a 24-hour response time on quote requests. Service coverage spans a wide geographic area, so homeowners in specific sub-communities of Huntington should confirm their address falls within the active service zone before scheduling.

3. Done Right Roofing

Done Right Roofing and Chimney is a family-owned contractor based in Huntington, NY. The company’s main focus is on residential roofing across different material types and provides 24-hour availability, including nights and weekends.

What they do: Roof replacement, emergency roof repair, leak repair, and inspection services for shingle, tile, flat, metal, and cedar shake roofs. They also handle chimney work, skylight installation, flashing repair, soffit and fascia repair, and storm and tree damage remediation.

Where they stand out: The 24/7 availability is a true differentiator for homeowners dealing with an active leak or storm damage who can’t wait till Monday morning. Done Right is licensed and insured, and no-cost estimates are standard. Financing options are available too, which helps homeowners who need work done faster but weren’t expecting the amount that will be spent. The company’s website doesn’t publish detailed warranty terms or material certifications, so homeowners should ask directly about coverage specifics at the time of the estimate.

4. A1 Roofing

A1 Roofing has operated as a family-owned business since 1981, serving Long Island, New York City, and New Jersey from two places: a Long Island office at 16 Platinum Ct in Medford, and the other one at Manhattan office on West 24th Street.

What they do: Residential and commercial roof replacement, repairs, new construction roofing, flat roofing, multi-family roofing, solar roof shingles, and ongoing maintenance. With more than 100 people in the field and office, A1 works across a much bigger project scope than most local independents.

Where they stand out: A1 is a factory-certified GAF Master Elite contractor and follows all work with a 100% satisfaction guarantee. The team practices following current safety protocols on every job. The company also runs a community “Free Roof” program, donating a full roof replacement to a family in need every year, and partnered with Stony Brook Children’s Hospital for a holiday toy drive in 2023. A1’s scale and multi-market reach mean it’s less of a hyper-local Huntington specialist and more of a regional operator, so homeowners who are comfortable with a smaller, neighborhood-focused crew may find the experience different from what a single-location company provides.

5. Triple Crown

Triple Crown Exteriors is a family-owned Suffolk County contractor with more than 10 years of work experience. The company started small, with a few roofing professionals and a pickup truck, and has since made a reputation across the county for workmanship and competitive pricing.

What they do: Residential roof replacement, new installation, and roof repair, plus siding, gutters, and windows. They serve communities all across Suffolk and Nassau County, including Holbrook, Farmingdale, Melville, Mastic Beach, and Calverton, and offer 24/7 emergency services for urgent situations.

Where they stand out: Triple Crown is BBB Accredited, licensed, and insured. The company markets itself on the combination of professional workmanship and personal, family-business service, a balance that gets showcased with homeowners who want accountability built into the relationship, not just a warranty document. Triple Crown’s web presence is a bit lesser on specific material certifications than some of the other companies on this list, so buyers comparing contractor information head-to-head should ask straightaway about manufacturer partnerships and warranty backing during the estimate.

What to ask a roofing contractor before you hire

No matter which company a homeowner selects, a few questions tell you the difference between a confident hire from a regrettable one.

Ask for proof of licensing and insurance before signing any contract. New York needs roofing contractors to carry both general liability and workers’ compensation; a suspicious activity in either exposes the homeowner if something goes wrong on the job.

Always ask what the labor warranty takes care of and how long it lasts. Manufacturer warranties on materials are standard, but labor coverage swings wildly from a single contractor to the next. Some offer two years; others go ten or thirty. The contract itself should spell out who handles a warranty claim if the original contractor closes up shop.

And ask about the nails. It’s a small detail that most homeowners never think to raise, but fastener quality affects long-term performance meaningfully. Hot-dip galvanized nails resist corrosion in Long Island’s coastal air far better than standard steel fasteners, and a company that clears them without getting asked is paying attention to the parts of a job that don’t show up in pictures.

Bottom Line

Roofing companies in Huntington, NY specializing in residential roof replacement take care of the gamut from single-location owner-operators to regional firms covering different counties. The right choice depends on project scope, timeline, warranty expectations, and how much starting contact a homeowner wants with whoever’s running the job. Certifications from Owens Corning or GAF carry real weight; they signal that a company meets a manufacturer’s installation standards and can unlock extra coverage that non-certified contractors easily can’t offer. Get at least two written estimates, compare warranty terms line by line, and confirm licensing with the Suffolk County Department of Labor before any work starts.

FAQs

How much does a residential roof replacement cost in Huntington, NY?

The cost depends on your roof size, materials, labor, and the amount of repair work needed. Getting quotes from a few local roofing companies can help you compare prices.

How long does it take to replace a residential roof?

Most home roof replacements take one to three days. However, the time may vary based on the roof size, weather, and type of work needed.

How do I choose the right roofing company in Huntington, NY?

Look for a company with good customer reviews, proper licenses, insurance, and experience in roof replacement. Also, ask for a written quote and warranty details before making your choice.




Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *