Choosing the right roof can be confusing and expensive. Many homes use either metal or asphalt roofing. I spent six months comparing these two popular materials to help you make a smart choice.
Keep reading to find out which roof is best for your home.
Cost Comparison
Metal roofing costs more to install at first. But it can save you money over time with less maintenance and fewer replacements needed.
Initial Installation Costs
Asphalt shingles cost less at first. The average price for asphalt roofing materials and labor is about $4,000 to $8,000 for a 2,000-square-foot home in the United States as of early 2024.
Roofers can install asphalt shingles quickly, which means lower labor costs.
Metal roofing materials cost more to buy. A steel or aluminum roof for the same house can cost between $10,000 and $16,000. Some high-end metals like copper may cost much more. Metal roofs take longer to install, which adds to labor expenses. Working with professional contractors who use job management software can make this process more efficient for homeowners. These platforms help contractors schedule crews, track materials, and monitor progress in real time, reducing delays and unexpected costs. Homeowners benefit from clearer timelines, accurate updates, and better communication, making a longer installation process less stressful and more
Many homeowners choose asphalt for the lower up-front cost, even though metal options last longer.
Long-term Value and Maintenance Expenses
Metal roofs often last 40 to 70 years. They hold up well against rain, snow, and high winds. Routine checks and minor fixes cost less over time. Most metal roofing needs little care except for cleaning off leaves or debris every few months.
“A new metal roof can save you thousands in repairs or replacements over the years.”.
Asphalt shingles usually need replacement after 20 years or so. Repairs are more common due to cracks or lost shingles from storms. Maintenance costs tend to add up because of frequent patching and replacing damaged parts.
Long-term investment in metal can mean lower expenses through its longer lifespan and less upkeep compared to asphalt options.
Lifespan and Durability
Metal roofs last longer than asphalt shingles. They can withstand harsh weather better, making them a strong choice for many homeowners.
Weather Resistance
Metal roofing stands up well to tough weather. Rain, wind, snow, and hail often bounce off without leaving marks. Strong winds above 120 mph rarely lift metal panels if installers place them right. Hail can dent the surface but does not usually cause leaks or damage below.
Asphalt shingles do not last as long under storms. Over time, they may crack or lose grains in heavy rain, and high winds over 80 mph can tear some loose. Hail may leave dents or even break shingles apart.
This means more repairs after harsh seasons compared to metal roofs.
Structural Integrity Over Time
Metal roofs are strong. They can last 40 to 70 years with proper care. These roofs handle extreme weather well. Heavy rain, snow, and high winds don’t damage them easily. Their structural integrity remains intact over time.
This makes metal a good long-term investment.
Asphalt shingles usually last around 15 to 30 years. They may require replacement sooner in harsh climates or if not maintained well. Over time, these shingles can crack and curl due to weather conditions.
This affects their ability to protect your home permanently. The choice you make will impact energy efficiency and maintenance needs later on, too. Next up is energy efficiency and how each material performs under the sun’s heat.
Energy Efficiency
Metal roofs reflect heat. This keeps homes cooler and saves on energy costs. Asphalt shingles absorb heat. They can make your home warmer, which may lead to higher energy bills.
Heat Reflection in Metal Roofs
Metal roofs reflect sunlight well. This means they keep homes cooler in hot weather. Studies show metal roofs can reduce cooling costs by 10 to 25 percent compared to asphalt shingles.
When deciding between the two options, it’s essential to evaluate the metal roof cost vs shingles to determine which aligns better with your budget and long-term goals.
They bounce back heat instead of soaking it up. Asphalt shingles absorb more heat, making homes warmer and increasing energy bills.
Choosing a metal roof is smart for energy efficiency. It helps save money over time by lowering air conditioning costs. Many homeowners enjoy this benefit. With the right color, metal roofs can trap less heat, too, adding to their appeal as an energy-saving option.
Heat Absorption in Asphalt Shingles
Asphalt shingles absorb more heat than metal roofs. This means homes with asphalt may get hotter in the summer. They can trap heat, raising indoor temperatures. This could lead to higher energy bills for cooling.
Studies show that darker shingles absorb even more heat than lighter ones. Homeowners might need to use air conditioning longer and at a higher setting. Metal roofs reflect sunlight better, keeping homes cooler overall.
So, while asphalt shingles are cost-effective upfront, they might not be the best choice for energy savings in hot climates.
Maintenance Requirements
Metal roofs need less upkeep compared to asphalt shingles. Asphalt may require more frequent repairs and inspections over time.
Frequency of Repairs
The frequency of repairs varies between metal and asphalt roofs. Asphalt roofing requires more frequent fixes. On average, homeowners may need to repair an asphalt roof every 5 to 10 years. Common issues include cracked shingles and leaks.
Metal roofs necessitate less maintenance overall. They can last up to 50 years or more with minimal repairs needed. Homeowners might only experience issues every 15-20 years, mostly due to severe weather or impact damage.
This makes metal roofs a better long-term investment for many people seeking durability and lower upkeep costs.
Ease of Maintenance
Metal roofs require less maintenance than asphalt shingles. They resist rust and damage from storms more effectively. This results in fewer repairs over time. Cleaning them is simple as well.
Just rinse with water and a soft brush.
Asphalt roofs can deteriorate quickly, especially in severe weather. You might need to patch or replace shingles more frequently. Regular inspections are important for both types, but metal roofs typically require less attention in general. Opting for metal may save you effort and money on maintenance in the future.
Conclusion
Choosing between metal and asphalt roofing is not easy. Each has its own strengths. Metal roofs are durable and energy-efficient, while asphalt shingles are often cheaper to install.
My experience shows that both types can last well, but they require different upkeep. It all comes down to your budget and what you value in a roof.
